Sunday, 10 March 2013

An evaluation of the skaven thrower in bloodbowl

Player Type
Thrower


Position
Thrower


Starting Line-up
Yes


Strengths
Starting skills, MA, Good skill progression


Weaknesses
AG3, Specialisation


 A lot of people would say that your gutter runners have better natural abilities and can act perfectly well as a thrower in a Skaven team. This is mainly due to their AG4 as opposed to the thrower’s AG3, and in that regard, I can see their point. The Thrower’s skills are crucial however, and although the numbers are close, the thrower when using the pass skill is slightly more effective at Rookie level. To my mind the crucial thing is that the Thrower has access to the passing skills set, and with accurate, nerves of steel, dump off and safe throw along with potentially strong arm or extra arms if you roll a double, his progression results in a considerably better thrower than a Gutter Runner will ever become. Coupled to that, there are already more roles to fulfil than you can have Gutter Runners to fill them, so losing one to operate in the Thrower’s role seems wasteful.

How to manage the downsides

The most annoying aspect of the Skaven Thrower is his agility of 3. The first way to address this as with any thrower, is to only throw the ball as far as you absolutely have to, you don’t get extra SPP’s for completing a long bomb at a -2 modifier, so why not throw a quick pass at +1 instead if you can? Set-up is a crucial part of this. The Skaven thrower has a great MA of 7, allowing him to reach all four corners of your half if set up in the central square. Don’t fall into this trap, set your Thrower up at the back of the board, this will mean your opponent is more likely to aim the kick into the gap in front of him instead of risking a touchback, and on that basis your Thrower can run forward, pick up the ball and keep moving forward, meaning you’re closer to any potential recipient than you would be if your Thrower starts in the central square and has to run backward to pick up, which makes any throws in subsequent turns easier.
Secondly, throw to players with the Catch and Diving Catch skills wherever possible. Your Thrower picks up SPP’s mainly through completed passes so if you can pass to a player who can re-roll the catch, or catch inaccurate passes, he will advance much quicker than if you’re passing to an unskilled receiver (save that for when your Gutter Runners are all in the knockout box!).  Skilling up your Thrower early on in a league makes winning games much easier later on, though it’s not an entirely bad idea to buy a deputy as your 16th player to take over when your primary Thrower dies (inevitably!).
The second issue then, is that your Thrower is going to develop a very specific set of skills aimed at getting the ball from the backfield to one of your receivers. The downside to this is what do you do with him once he’s made that pass, which may be in the first or second turn of your drive (though hopefully it won’t take you more than 3 turns to score). Some would advocate spreading his skill base to allow him to act as a defender in the backfield when you’ve not got the ball, or to only use him on the offensive drives and use a gutter runner instead on defence. I tend to keep my Thrower on the pitch at all times, both offensive and defensive drives. On defence he has the kick skill, meaning I can place the ball more accurately (and in the case of slow teams, deeper into their half of the pitch) and after that he acts as a last ditch line of defence if the opponent gets through. I don’t give him any defensive skills however (such as block, tackle etc) because with Skaven the one thing you absolutely must be able to do is transfer that ball well to your Gutter Runners and the more skills he has to enable him to achieve this, the better. In order to manage this then, keep your Thrower to a support role, let him provide assists on the whole, and if necessary he can make the odd block. Keep his action as late in the turn as you can however, because if one of your other defenders manages to knock the ball free, your Thrower is the ideal guy to retrieve it and get it out of the danger zone (especially once you give him Nerves of Steel and Safe Throw so he doesn’t have to dodge out of any tackle zones). By doing this, you limit the offence your opponent is going to put on the Thrower, of course in an ideal world their cage would never get to the point where your Thrower is the solitary defender, but this game doesn’t work like that.

How to maximise the strengths

Early on, you’re really going to be grateful for those starting skills. Sure hands means that your Thrower is more effective at picking up the ball than an AG4 player (just) and is better at throwing an accurate pass to all bar long bomb range compared to your Gutter Runners. So as with the above section, make short passes (ideally you should be passing at least 3 times per game). There’s absolutely nothing wrong with making a short pass to a Gutter Runner, then handing it off back to the Thrower to do the same next turn (just make sure you’re out of range of the opposition if you do fumble a pass/catch), this will really speed up the Thrower’s development.
Second, make use of his speed. This is especially key if you’re going for a one-turn touchdown. I mentioned before that you should set up your Thrower at the back of the field. This is to make use of his speed. Unless your opponent has the kick skill he’s likely to aim the kick-off in the centre of the pitch so ensure you don’t get a touchback (if it does land off the pitch that’s one in the win column for your set-up!). Odds are therefore that the ball will land (on average) 3-4 squares away from the centre point of your half. Your Thrower can then swoop on it and get within Short Pass range of one of your flanking Gutter Runners. If they haven’t got the speed for the OTTD, set them a couple of squares back from the centreline and you may even be able to make a quick pass.
An alternative if you want to play safe is to set your Thrower up in the central square, and then in your first turn retrieve it, then retreat to the back of your half out of range of being sacked (preferably to one side as this helps to prevent you being closed down for the throw next turn.
Finally then is your Thrower’s skill set. Ok, so most Throwers have access to the Passing skills, but the Skaven Thrower’s MA, combined with the available skills and access on doubles to mutations means he can really develop into a top notch distributor. He’s a specialist, has just the one job so make sure you take advantage and do that job very well indeed

Do you start a league with one?

Errr. Yes!

What skills can they take?

Block
Well there are plenty of people that would advocate taking block on your Thrower so that he can act better as a last ditch defender. I disagree, on your offensive drive you want your Thrower skilled up to the max to distribute the ball well, and on defence, if you want a guy with block use a lineman or a stormvermin.  Block doesn’t help the Thrower perform his primary task, so I’d advise against it.

Dauntless
It’s a blocking skill, and your Thrower should be limiting the amount of this that he does, to avoid being blocked in return, so I’d leave this one in the box.

Dirty Player
As with the Stormvermin, Gutter Runners and Rat Ogre, you don’t want to risk your specialist being sent off, so don’t foul with him, and if you’re not fouling with him there’s no point in taking this skill.

Fend
Could be useful with a Thrower if you do happen to get cornered and blocked. His MA should minimise the number of occasions when this can happen though and as such you shouldn’t need this skill very often. On that basis, I wouldn’t take it.

Frenzy
Another blocking skill. This one could be useful if you use your Thrower as a backfield defender, if only to look for opportunities to push opponents into the crowd. You probably don’t want it on your principal Thrower though.

Kick
Despite the fact that this skill doesn’t directly affect his distribution of the ball, I’d take this skill as one of the first your Thrower gets (probably Accurate first, unless you roll a stat increase or a double). It means you can reliably and regularly place the ball within a couple of squares of the endzone, and against slower teams that’s crucial, as it gives you much more time to organise and mobilise your defensive screen.

Kick off Return
I can see why this skill might be useful, but what I would also say is that your MA is high enough to ensure it’s not a necessity (unlike the Orc Thrower for example, who could struggle to reach a kick-off without it)

Pass Block
Leave it to your Gutter Runners would be my advice, his AG of 3 means he’s less likely to actually make an interception anyway. I might consider it as a 6th skill, maybe, but even then there are probably better options available.

Pro
Don’t see the need for this on a Thrower, you can only re-roll and individual roll once, and with Sure Hands and Pass as starting skills he probably wouldn’t use it anyway.

Shadowing
I do like this skill for its nuisance value and again, a case could be made that when the Thrower is in defensive mode, shadowing could be vital in saving the odd touchdown by forcing dodge tests. In practice though, it’s a skill that would be nice, but doesn’t help the Thrower fulfil his primary role.

Strip Ball
Best used on a player that’s going to be sacking the ball carrier, I’d leave it off your Thrower as he should be assisting blocks, not making them (unless circumstances are dire indeed).

Tackle
Best used when blocking players with dodge or causing receivers to pass their dodge roll without a re-roll, you could certainly include it if you have a defensive Thrower in your team. But why would you, he’s 20,000gp more than a lineman and though he comes with 2 skills, neither is suited to this job.

Wrestle
Another of the defensive skills, and as with Shadowing/Strip Ball/Tackle, it just doesn’t fall within the remit of my Thrower.

Accurate
Always my first choice skill for a Thrower, unless I get an Agility stat increase or a double. Effectively makes him AG4 for the purposes of making a pass.

Dump Off
It’s not a skill I use very much with Skaven, mainly because the Thrower is speedy enough to avoid attention of the opposition until he’s got rid of the ball, when it becomes redundant. I’ve played against it plenty though and If you’ve got a Gutter Runner nearby and you’re running a cage it would be highly frustrating!

Hail Mary Pass
Love the idea of this skill, it reminds me of a goal line clearance in football (soccer for you Americans out there). Doesn’t seem to work right in the computer version of the game though, as the default is to always use this skill, and if you change the setting to ask then the throw always seems to fail. In the tabletop version though you can just imagine the situation, two turns of the match to go, the Chaos cage has broken through the main defence but a brave Gutter Runner manages to leap in and strip the ball from the carrier, it bounces free of the cage whereupon the Thrower snatches it up and hurls it to the far end of the pitch, saving the touchdown and winning the game. It’s one of those skills I’d take when all other avenues are exhausted.

Leader
A lot of people seem to advocate taking leader on your Thrower, giving the team that extra re-roll for a much smaller amount in TV than buying an extra re-roll. I’d be more inclined to take it on a linerat to be honest, though it’s not a skill I’ve ever bothered with, extra re-rolls are affordable enough after a few matches and with enough cheerleaders/assistant coaches then you can usually get one or two per match on the kick-off table.

Nerves of Steel
Very useful skill this, one of the basic principles of bloodbowl is to roll the dice as little as possible for agility tests, so being able to pass out of a tackle zone without modification or dodging into the open is like gold!

Safe Throw
Similarly to Nerves of Steel, anything that reduces the chance of your throw going wrong is good, so being able to keep hold of the ball on most fumbles, and being able to cancel interceptions half the time is very useful indeed. Probably not one of the first skills to take, but it’s definitely in the top 5.

What are good options for doubles skill rolls?

Catch
Not high on the list, I’d be surprised if you saw this on a Thrower, but consider the scenario mentioned earlier of passing with your Thrower and then handing off back to them, Catch makes this much more reliable if you’re looking to give completion points to other players.

Dodge
Similar to block, if you’re worried about your Thrower being scragged (and you shouldn’t be) then Dodge will help him stay on his feet.

Leap
Again, very useful if you’re going to be pouncing on a ball stripped free in a cage and hurling it upfield, leap can either be used to get you into the centre of a cage without having to dodge with that -3 modifier, or get out of a cage if you’re being marked hard. Beware though, it’s probably best used in extremis, as the Thrower’s base AG3 means half the time you’ll land on your face. Of course, by only using it when in desperate need, you can guarantee that Nuffle will always make you fail.

Strong Arm
Oh yes, yes yes yes. Combined with Accurate and Pass, this means you’ll be on target with three out of every four long bombs you attempt (and if you’re passing to someone with diving catch…). I probably wouldn’t take it in preference to Extra Arms due to the philosophy of not throwing the ball further than you have to, but if you get a second double then grab this skill with both hands.

Big Hand
Remember that secondary Thrower with Leap, Hail Mary Pass and Nerves of Steel? He’d definitely benefit from Big Hand as well.

Extra Arms
Well this skill is most definitely a benefit to the Thrower, I’d generally view it as an either/or with an Agility Increase, taking that in preference, but if you’re up to your 5th/6th skill and can’t think what else to take, go for it, you’ll be able to pick up in a single tackle zone on a 2+, with a re-roll, which can’t be a bad thing!

What are the best stat increases to take?

Agility, agility, agility, and if you get a second roll, Agility. Most of the things you’re going to be asking your Thrower to do are based on Agility rolls, and though some of his skill let him re-roll those attempts, an increased agility will make them much easier in the first place. I wouldn’t say no to a Thrower with AG5, Accurate, Kick, Safe Throw, Pass and Sure Hands, would you? MA and AV increases would be useful for reducing passing distances and making him more survivable, but don’t bother with ST.

What are the best skill combinations?

As I discussed earlier, I consider the Thrower to be a specialist and as such there’s only one build I’d consider making for the first Thrower in my own team.
1.       Accurate
2.       Agility Increase
3.       Kick
4.       Safe Throw
5.       Nerves of Steel
6.       Extra Arms
If you do manage to roll lots of doubles then potentially Big Hand may be worth considering, particularly in combination with Nerves of Steel and Safe Throw for retrieving the ball from tackle zones and clearing it from your own half. I’d also consider Hail Mary Pass for this, however in my experience there seems to be a bug with this if you’re playing the game on a computer and it fails the throw every time.

As a second Thrower, you could develop him more along defensive lines for playing in the other half.
1.       Hail Mary Pass
2.       Leap
3.       Nerves of Steel
4.       Big Hand
After this, the player’s development is pretty open, you could give him Jump Up to make sure he can reach the ball if he’s knocked down, or block/dodge to keep him on his feet more, the options here are too many to list.

Final thoughts
The Thrower is key to the way I play the Skaven team, and is right up there with the Elves as the best in the game (ok, the Elves natural agility of 4 does consign him to tier 2, but he’s definitely better than the Human options (including Amazons and Norse), with Orcs languishing at the bottom.  I would definitely argue for a highly specialised Thrower on offense, possibly using a more defensive minded option on defence once my team is a bit more developed.